Reality shows like Love Island are the peak of entertainment. They allow you to escape your reality and waltz into the unscripted personal lives of others.
Plus, everyone loves a great love or spicy one-night stand story, and you know what’s even better? Seeing it in real-time.
In Love Island, a couple of contestants come together, live in a cozy villa, and take turns trying to find their next soulmate and stand a chance to win a cash prize.
The exciting part is that viewers choose which couple deserves to win. If you’d love to check out what other Reality shows like Love Island are available for viewing and judging pleasure, check out the top 16 picks.
1. Are You The One (AYTO)
- Available On: Paramount+
- IMDb Rating: 6.6/10
Well, are you the one? You’ve probably heard it a lot, so it’s fitting that the organizers named the show after a famous dating catchphrase.
AYTO brings single contestants together for 10 weeks in one place. They collect data to find perfect matches and interview the contestants, their friends, family, and pets for more details.
Contestants must find the perfect match the algorithm chooses to qualify for the $1 million cash prize.
They can engage in activities and go on a date to the truth booth, where their butterflies’ wings are either clipped or allowed to flutter some more.
2. FBoy Island
- Available On: Tunes, Vudu, Google Play, and Amazon Instant Video (Buy).
- IMDb Rating: 5.4/10
FBoy Island is a gem among the many reality shows like Love Island, but here you might not find true love.
Instead, you’ll encounter many attractive individuals and figure out who is genuinely looking for love and who is just playing around.
The exciting part is watching which of the three ladies can pick a good guy by the show’s end.
If you’re a feminist, you might want to avoid this show because every woman receives $100,000 just for participating.
If a woman chooses a fboy, not only does she end up with a broken heart, but the fboy also walks away with the $100,000.
However, if you’re all about entertainment, laughter, and seeing women in swimsuits, FBoy Island is a must-watch.
3. Love Is Blind
- Available On: Netflix
- IMDb Rating: 6.2/10
Ever been on a blind date with no idea what is waiting for you on the other end?
It could be an exciting or nerve-racking experience, and the producers of Love is Blind brilliantly incorporated that into a reality show.
The show hit the airwaves in 2020 and was streamed exclusively on Netflix.
In Love is Blind, two people talk in a pod, fall in love, and get engaged without meeting in person.
This aligns with the idea that true love goes beyond appearance, possessions, or status, as beautifully expressed by Oscar Wilde.
4. Sexy Beasts
- Available On: iTunes, Amazon Instant Video, Google Play, and Vudu (Buy).
- IMDb Rating: 5.6/10
Sexy Beast is one of the British reality shows like Love Island. The contestants must select each other based on more than just physical attractiveness.
Four contestants wear unattractive animal or mythical creature costumes and interact with each other.
Of the four, only one contestant is single and is pursued by the other three in prosthetic beast disguises. After a personality battle, two suitors are eliminated, leaving only one remaining.
For fans of reality shows like Love Island, this concept might disappoint, but the entire process, including the unveiling, is worth watching.
5. Too Hot To Handle (THTH)
- Available On: Netflix
- IMDb Rating: 4.7/10
Since its debut on Netflix in 2020, Too Hot to Handle has sizzled into one of the most popular reality shows like Love Island.
But some critics insist it would be even hotter if the narrator’s burns were left out.
While other reality shows let contestants go wild with hookups, THTH keeps things cookie-cool by stashing them away.
Each of the 10 contestants is allowed to flirt and befriend others in the house while maintaining the sort of physical contact that should be rated G.
Once the rules are broken, a chunk gets taken out of the $100,000 grand prize, and substandard participation is rewarded with an eviction.
6. Paradise Hotel
- Available On: Amazon Instant Video or Vudu (Buy).
- IMDb Rating: 5.1/10
The first season of Paradise Hotel kicked off in 2003, captivating audiences in the US and spreading its wings to 10+ countries.
But after 16 years, it got the boot in 2019 for not making the grade. No more peeking at 11 stunning singles vying for love and that sweet prize money.
Just like Big Brother, Paradise Hotel lets the housemates play eviction games, with viewers getting to vote in replacements.
Though finding love isn’t the primary goal, some lucky couples do end up making real-life connections.
7. Ex On The Beach
- Available On: Paramount Plus
- IMDb Rating: 4.7/10
Imagine being stuck for weeks with your ex, whether you like it or not! That’s the twisted genius of Ex On The Beach, throwing singles back in with their past flames, hoping to find new sparks.
The only thing more puzzling than the drama is how beautiful everyone is, almost like a setup.
Some singles don’t walk away reconnected with their ex but with newfound friendships.
If you get tired of the regular singles and exes drama, head to the celebrity series for something fresh and new.
8. Bachelor In Paradise
- Available On: Hulu
- IMDb Rating: 5.3/10
Bachelor in Paradise is the ultimate showdown for survivors of other reality shows like Love Island.
It’s their last shot at finding love, and sparks may finally fly. Suitors approach bachelorettes with cards, hoping for a match or a miss.
In this paradise, love can be snatched away quicker than you can say; swipe right.
New arrivals come and go like the seasons, and contestants’ emotions flip faster than a pancake on a hot griddle.
9. Temptation Island
- Available On: Fubo, Hulu + Live TV, Sling, DirecTV Stream
- IMDb Rating: 6.1/10
Imagine stocking your fridge full of chocolate bars when you have a chocolate problem.
It’s similar to lodging couples and gorgeous singles together for a couple of weeks, trying to see who hops off to the other side and never returns.
It’s hard to imagine why anyone would want to get together through a process like this.
Well, 76 seasons and 7 seasons after the show still goes on, and people sign up to get their commitment to each other tested.
10. Singletown
- Available On: Apple TV and Chromecast.
- IMDb Rating: 5.8/10
Sharing a slight similarity with Temptation Island, Singletown is an epic reality drama full of twists and turns.
Several couples take a break from real-life relationships to get on the show and taste the single life.
To make it more interesting, the exes left behind spend time in another apartment watching the show.
Follow participants as they try to stay true to their partners on the other side or dive happily into the waiting waters.
If you’re thinking of reality shows like Love Island, this fits the bill but without the budget and Lain Stirling.
11. Married At First Sight
- Available On: Philo TV, Sling TV, FuboTV, and Hulu.
- IMDb Rating: 6.2/10
Well, if it’s not love at first sight, it’s better looking and more volatile sibling, Married At First Sight.
In this experiment, relationship experts match singles based on wits and research and ship them straight to the altar.
To embark on a journey like this takes a lot of guts, with a sprinkle of frustration from being unable to meet someone compatible off-screen.
The couple gets a first glance at each other on the altar in front of witnesses, which may include friends and family.
As far as reality shows like Love Island go, Married, At First Sight provides peak entertainment.
You get to watch each couple blossom or fall apart after a spontaneous marriage.
12. The Ultimatum
- Available On: Netflix
- IMDb Rating: 5.5/10
The Ultimatum hit Netflix on April 6th, 2022, and sent over 100 million viewers into a frenzy within a month. It’s one of those top-tier reality shows like Love Island.
Here, the deal is that couples are thrown together, and they face a big fat ultimatum, marry, or part ways.
But there’s more! Each couple gets split up and paired with someone new for three wild weeks.
They cohabitate, then switch back to their original partners, leaving them with a major decision to make.
It’s intense and gripping, and you’ll find it hard to sit because you will be cheering for your favorite duo.
13. Survivor
- Available On: Hulu, Disney+
- IMDb Rating: 7.5/10
Survivor takes the concept of “survival of the fittest” and cranks it up to a level that would make Charles Darwin blush.
Contestants battle it out in different challenges that test their strength, mental agility, and ability to keep their cool under whatever creepy crawlies the producers can throw at them.
This reality show is an experience that makes the most intense episodes of Love Island seem like a casual stroll on the beach.
It is the ultimate test of human endurance, resilience, and ability to eat disgusting things in the name of victory.
You’ll be exposed to a new form of alliances, where there is manipulation, backstabbing, and lies wrapped in so much finesse.
While you sit at home, stuffing your faces with popcorn, you’ll be thankful you’re not the one getting voted off.
14. Heart Signal
- Available On: Viki, Disney Plus.
- IMDb Rating: 6.7/10
First off, the concept behind the Heart Signal is a stroke of genius. Just as reality shows like Love Island, this one carries a few extra beats of excitement.
A group of young, attractive individuals are gathered together in a stunning villa, their hearts aflutter with anticipation.
And speaking of potential love interests, there are unexpected twists and turns to look out for.
Hearts are broken, and love triangles are formed, respectively.
Also, the participants are equipped with heart rate monitors, giving you the ultimate gauge of their love-struck shenanigans.
15. Indian Matchmaking
- Available On: Netflix
- IMDb Rating: 6.7/10
Indian Matchmaker is the spicy curry of reality shows like Love Island.
The film is like a Bollywood version of Love Island, where the drama unfolds in colorful sarees.
It opens up the chaos of romance and the cultural nuances of arranged marriages.
A group of single, eligible bachelors and bachelorettes, all dressed to impress, mingling at a luxurious Indian palace.
There is the matchmaker, Sima Taparia, who expertly juggles the hopes of the young, unsuspecting participants.
As they go on their dates, you will witness a delightful mix of cultural clashes and heartwarming connections.
16. 12 Dates of Christmas
- Available On: HBO Max, Apple Tv (Buy).
- IMDb Rating: 5.7/10
12 Dates of Christmas is like when Love Island meets the holiday season.
It’s a beautiful world of reality shows where love, drama, and cringe-worthy moments collide. The heroine, Holly, finds herself in a peculiar predicament.
She has twelve dates, one for each day leading up to Christmas. She must spend time with different suitors while determining if they’re naughty or nice.
But as with any good reality show, things get more complicated, like when you try to untangle a string of Christmas lights.
